Banner triangles

3D printing – social responsibility vs legal risks

Recent news reports have highlighted how 3D printing can be applied to manufacture components for much needed medical equipment during the current COVID-19 pandemic. But what are the intellectual property risks?

Background

The press have highlighted the case of two Italian volunteers with 3D printing equipment who produced a number of vital valves urgently needed by a hospital in Brescia, Italy for connecting breathing equipment to oxygen tanks. The Italian volunteers, who run a small start-up manufacturing company, printed a prototype valve for testing from a component donated by the hospital within a period of three hours, and started production shortly after the hospital confirmed the valve was acceptable. A number of the valves were supplied by the volunteers at a price of $1 – the usual price tag is higher than this. To date, at least 10 lives have been saved.

3D printing covers a variety of processes in which liquid or powder material is applied in successive layers to build a three-dimensional shape. The technology is not new - it has been around in some form since the 80s, but the evolution of 3D printing processes means the technology can now be used to manufacture very complex parts, with a high degree of precision. The process is repeatable and cost effective. Products can be manufactured quickly with minimal waste.

A prerequisite for producing any 3D printed part is a digital 3D model or a computer aided design (CAD) file. It is very easy to produce a digital 3D model by scanning an existing component or part – which can often be sourced very easily. The Italian volunteers reportedly scanned a valve from the hospital’s own stock.

On its face, 3D printing presents an ideal opportunity for any socially responsible volunteers or manufacturers with the necessary equipment to quickly step in to the production of components in short supply, including parts for life saving medical equipment.

What 3D manufacturers need to know

Manufacturers should be aware of the complex intellectual property issues concerned with this 3D printing technology.
Parts such as valves or other medical devices and equipment are capable of protection by patent and/or registered design. Unregistered design rights and copyright will also apply to the part itself and/or the digital model or CAD file. Some or all of these rights might apply in respect of a single component.

Quote mark icon

In scanning a component such as a valve, and manufacturing a part using 3D printing equipment, there is a risk that this action will infringe an existing patent, design or copyright which protects the component, leading to an injunction or claim from the rights holder for damages or other remedies

Disclaimer

This information is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It is recommended that specific professional advice is sought before acting on any of the information given.

Insights

Read the latest articles and commentary from Shoosmiths or you can explore our full insights library.